Compare Ingredients

Side-by-side comparison of safety profiles, dosage, and evidence

Vitamin D vs Calcium

PropertyVitamin DCalcium
Scientific nameCholecalciferol (D3)Calcium carbonate / citrate
Safety ratingGenerally SafeConditionally Safe
Evidence levelStrongStrong
CategoryFat-Soluble VitaminsMajor Minerals
RDA600 IU; 800 IU if >70y1,000 mg; 1,200 if >50y (F)
Tolerable UL4,000 IU2,500 mg
Clinical pearlCheck 25(OH)D in all at-risk patients (BMI >30, age >65, dark skin, northern latitude) [21]. D3 is 87% more potent than D2 at raising serum levels [4]. Prescribe with a fat-containing meal for optimal absorption [7]. Co-supplement with K2 (MK-7) for bone and vascular benefit [17]. Target 30–50 ng/mL; >50 rarely adds benefit and >150 risks toxicity [1][21]. Large bolus dosing (>300,000 IU) paradoxically increases falls — use daily/weekly dosing [11][25]. The VITAL trial showed no cancer or CVD prevention at 2,000 IU/day but did reduce autoimmune disease by 22% [12][13].Calcium is the cornerstone of skeletal health but only works in concert with vitamin D and vitamin K. Food sources are preferred over supplements. Calcium carbonate requires acid (take with meals); calcium citrate does not (ideal for PPI users and post-bariatric patients). Never exceed 500 mg per dose [1] [5].
Key interactionsSee profileSee profile
US products (DSLD)3,5527,096
Comparison generated by SupplementIndex. Data is for educational purposes. Consult a healthcare professional before combining supplements.